“There’s this trick I have on the piano. When I reach a section of music that totally trips up my fingers and mangles my confidence, I call on the experts. I put the score away, close my eyes, and imagine I’m in Carnegie Hall. There’s no audience, I’m not even onstage. I’m sitting in the first row next to Beethoven, Mozart, and Gershwin. It’s just the four of us. I tell them the problem. Then I wait patiently for their guidance. They’ve never failed me before… I present them with today’s quandary, only this one is of the nonmusical variety. What we have, gentlemen, is a girl who can’t remember her first time.”
Alex went to a concert with her friends on a rare night when they were allowed to leave their boarding school, Themis Academy. She drank too much, and woke up in the bed of a fellow student she didn’t know or remember from the night before. Slowly, details of the night trickled back, and the horrible realization dawned on her that none of what happened that night had been her choice. She had said no to Carter, but he ignored her.
After confiding in her friends, they seek out a secret committee called ‘The Mockingbirds’, made up of students with a desire to replace the schools lackadaisical to nonexistent discipline system with a strict but fair arrangement. They act as a “for the students, by the students” kind of committee. The Mockingbirds help Alex to recover from the pain of being date-raped, and to move on from the all-consuming fear and distraction that followed, as well as working towards getting a confession and an appropriate punishment for Carter.
It was refreshing to read a book about a girl like Alex who didn’t act like a helpless victim. Unlike the meek and self-isolated character in the book ‘Speak’, which ‘The Mockingbirds’ has been compared to because of the similar teenage rape storyline, Alex takes matters into her own hands and asks for help. As a result, she’s able to work towards a normal life in which she can feel safe. I think this is an ideal model for girls who have experienced similar injustices. Isolation is not the answer. I appreciated that Alex was never alone throughout the process; someone was always supporting her.
The author of ‘The Mockingbirds’, Daisy Whitney, showed accurately and without reservations how quickly a rumor can spread through the grapevine, (true or untrue), as well as how cruel teenagers can be. I was shocked but in agreement with how oblivious adults sometimes can be to things going on right under their noses, even though they were teenagers once too. I think the idea that Themis’ students are assumed to be flawless and unable to inflict harm on one another is creative and mirrors a reality in normal high schools. There is a lot that happens in schools that never reaches the ears of those in power at the school, often to the detriment of those involved. While Themis’ disciplinary system without the student-run Mockingbirds could never fly in real schools, it is an exaggerated version of the reality of oblivious teachers.
While it’s not a cheery or particularly funny book, ‘The Mockingbirds’ is an important read. It’s well written, the concept is unique, and the characters are very likeable. It’s one of those books that you’ll be happy you read, because you come away feeling like you better understand how Alex and other date-rape victims feel as they deal with the consequences of a huge problem in our world.